I decided in advance that I'd cover these two episodes in my next post, a decision I made with only a vague recollection of the episodes in question. And after seeing them, for a while I felt like I should cover them each in their own post. I felt this, not because either one particularly merits a standalone post, but because they're each so different, in so many ways. While This Year's Model is a solid, enjoyable example of the early "issue" episodes, The Lab Brat is probably one of the weakest episodes in the entire series, and falls into basically every trap that the show usually avoided so carefully. But while the episodes have very little in common, their lack of commonality is itself a worthy topic of consideration. In particular, I have to account for the strange fact that while This Year's Model is more effective as an episode of television, it's actually The Lab Brat that is more important in the way it moves the series. Let's figure out why.
2 Summary
Short: Ms. Li announces that two talent scouts from the Amazon Modeling Agency are to visit Lawndale High to look for potential models.
Long: We learn that Daria's bedroom walls are padded because the previous resident was a schizophrenic; Daria worries that her mother will forcibly redecorate. At Lawndale, Ms. Li announces that the Amazon Modeling Agency will be holding tryouts at their school. The representatives (Claude and the delightfully named Romonica) show up during economics class to gush over all the students (and Mrs. Bennett). Daria complains about this to her (sympathetic) parents, immediately before Quinn announces that she has been accepted into modeling class. After a negotiation between Helen and Romonica (who is getting a Brazilian wax at the time), Helen agrees to let Quinn attend, but insists that Daria observe, in exchange for an embargo on redecorating her room. Brittany is kicked out of the class, causing her great distress, particularly when some male students (including, at Claude's insistence, Kevin) participate in a rather intimate pretend photo shoot, which involves the boys (reluctantly) taking off their shirts. Ms. Li happens by and angrily breaks up the class. At the next day's assembly, before she can announce the winner of the modeling contract, a representative of a mercenary solider outfit marches on stage, claiming to have been invited by Ms. Li. The press follows in his wake. The next day at breakfast, as Quinn laments her lost opportunity, Daria reads that the contract was awarded to Kevin. He, however, is miserable at his first photo shoot, as Romonica and Claude both regret their choice.
The Lab Brat
Short: Ms. Barch pairs up the students for experiments involving the conditioning of a mouse.
Short: Ms. Barch pairs up the students for experiments involving the conditioning of a mouse.
Long: Ms. Barch, Lawndale's biology teacher, gives an explanation of operant conditioning centered around her ex-husband, who recently divorced her after 22 years of marriage. The students are paired up rather vindictively; Daria is paired with Kevin, and Upchuck with Brittany. Their project: to train a mouse to run through a maze, using their choice of positive or negative reinforcement. The cable TV is broken at Kevin's house, so he asks to work on the project at Daria's, where he is transfixed by "The Pigskin Channel", leaving Daria to work on the maze in peace. Meanwhile, Helen is encouraging Daria to make friends with Kevin, since he's so popular, while Quinn attempts to date him for the same reasons (Jake just likes having another man around the house). Meanwhile, Upchuck has revealed that through "accidental" telephotography, he has evidence that Brittany (while broken up with Kevin for a week) spent some intimate moments in the back seat of a rival QB's car. He uses this leverage to extract menial labor from Brittany, adding to the frustration she already feels at Daria "stealing" her boyfriend. As Kevin's time with Daria makes her even more popular, Brittany, in desperation, steals Daria and Kevin's lab mouse, returning it only when Daria promises to "return" Kevin. Unfortunately, Brittany's younger brother tortured the mouse while it was in their house, but Daria rescues the situation by explaining to Ms. Barch that this was a textbook example of negative reinforcement, and gets an A. Kevin, however, gets a D, while Upchuck and Brittany receive an F, as Ms. Barch demands that Brittany, not Upchuck, explain their experiment to her. The next day Kevin approaches Daria to invite... Quinn to an upcoming party.
3. Recapitulation
These episodes, among other dichotomies, embody the two approaches that a show with Daria's goals and setting could take: Issue of the Week vs. Relationship Drama.
These episodes, among other dichotomies, embody the two approaches that a show with Daria's goals and setting could take: Issue of the Week vs. Relationship Drama.
This Year's Model is emphatically in the first category. It's easy to forget now in this "Golden Age of Television," but issue-of-the-week shows were still a staple of television programming at the time (the year Daria premiered, the Emmy for Outstanding Dramatic Series went to Law & Order!). And there's no doubt that this sort of thing was in Daria's DNA; the MTV generation grew up with Very Special Episodes, and I say this as somebody that vividly remembers, not just watching, but eagerly anticipating Cartoon All-Stars to the Rescue. Really, all of Daria up to this point had been at least borderline Very Special, and you could easily see the production staff, at this point in the run, regarding This Year's Model as to some extent their masterwork, the specimen type of a Daria episode, to point out to future writers.
And yet, in the very next episode, all of that is cast aside in favor of relationship drama. Now, it goes without saying that relationship drama transcends generations (but then, so does issue-of-the-week, q.v. South Park). But it was nonetheless more than usually at the forefront when Daria premiered, at least in its target demo: Dawson's Creek, Party of Five, Beverly Hills 90210, and Felicity were all currently on the air. In fact, Daria was seen by some at MTV as a successor to My So-Called Life, according to some interviews. (Note: I originally wrote that I'd found that information in a specific interview, which I linked to. But somehow the link information got lost in a copy/paste somewhere, and I haven't recovered it. So I guess just Google it and hope for the best.) The Lab Brat has no "political" interests, no broader issues that it wants to explore. The closest it gets is Ms. Barch's rants about her ex-husband, which are essentially ignored by every other character. The dramas are all interpersonal, centered around things like the competition for Kevin's (and Quinn's) affections, the fluctuations of Daria's popularity, Upchuck's attempts to sow discord, etc. It's a different episode from any that were made thus far, and also, as I said, one of the worst.
And yet. It's not a coincidence that the characters (Romonica and Claude) introduced in TYM are never seen again, while the character of Ms. Barch, introduced in TLB, becomes a recurring character (completely eclipsing Mrs. Bennett, by the way). The fact is that TLB is both an unpleasant slog AND a breath of fresh air. We needed to see Daria fighting for herself, and not her principles. In the course of these two episodes, Daria makes a crucial transition from observer to participant. And so of course TLB is an unpleasant episode, because, after all, Daria had been holding herself back from the world for reasons which were perfectly understandable! In TYM, Daria could still keep her distance and negotiate from power. She extracts a concession from her mother for nothing, and then spends much of the episode literally sitting in the audience, watching others suffer, and only acting in secret (nobody ever discovers who recruited the mercenary on Lawndale's behalf). In TLB, those barriers are broken down, and Daria is forced into the lives of Kevin, Brittany, Upchuck, and Quinn; heck, even the J's want to talk to her. Daria can no longer afford to stand aloof from them. Her grade is on the line, and even her own home and family are being invaded and corrupted by those she despises. Meanwhile Jane, who has been observing from a safe distance since long before she met Daria, shows no particular inclination to get her own hands dirty. Daria actually suffers in this episode, instead of theatrically declaring herself to be suffering. The difference is palpable.
And so ultimately, the value of The Lab Brat, for all its many flaws, is that it finally puts the focus of the show squarely on, well, Daria. Despite the fact that the show is named for her, and is told from her perspective, she is a difficult character to get to know, by her own design. The barriers she's put up are as resistant to her own self-exploration as they are to outsiders (remember what she chose to write about at the coffee house. It wasn't exactly Song Of Myself). And so the show, in its early going, found itself talking about Daria's surroundings; it might as well have been called Lawndale High, or The Morgendorffers. But with The Lab Brat, the show found a way, however ugly, to break through and force its central character to acknowledge herself a part of the world. Of course, she's still good old monotone, impervious Daria, and rightly so. But the stakes have been raised, and that's never a bad thing.
4. Closeup
Ok, all that said: The Lab Brat, important though it may be, is also just plain bad, for reasons I've been struggling to pin down. In the end, I guess it just boils down to inconsistency. The episode's universe and motivations are inconsistent both within the episode, and in the context of the larger series.
Take Helen, for example. In TYM, she deals assertively with Daria, Quinn, and Romonica, maintaining a consistent and mature view of modelling as a career, and an appropriate (and therefore limited) trust in Quinn's ability to navigate it. True, she is outmaneuvered by Daria on the subject of redecorating her room, but not egregiously so. In TLB, on the other hand, Daria makes fun of her to her face while Helen remains oblivious. Moreover, she is delighted by the idea that Daria will be spending time with Kevin.
Now, this could just be written off as a young series finding its way, and the Daria-Helen relationship is definitely one that grows and changes as the series goes on. But even at this point, it's bizarre to see Helen treating "QB" as a desirable rank. If she did, it's hard to see why she married Jake, a third-string punter if ever there was one. And ignoring Daria's mockery is even more inexplicable. She may be false with her children, but she is always present in their conversations. Indeed, the very same scene has Daria saying "Do you really believe that?" to which Helen responds "Believe? In what sense?" Which is insincere, yes, but hardly oblivious.
Another inconsistency, and one that I confess annoys me more than it might annoy others, is the handling of The Pigskin Channel. Now, The Pigskin Channel is clearly a knockoff of ESPN Classic (at the time still known as Classic Sports Network). The show describes itself as airing "Classic football games 24 hours a day -- every day, all this month." Which is fine as far as it goes (although, "all this month"? What the hell are they planning to air NEXT month?). The problem is that, for the rest of the episode, Kevin (and Jake) behave as if the show is airing live games. It's not just that the level of Kevin's investment makes no sense for somebody watching years-old games (even those featuring "his team"). But Kevin also specifically suggests that the games are live; when Daria tries to tell him there's a problem he says "The game got cancelled?" followed by "They're running the game opposite the..." Which, even if the game WAS live, makes absolutely no sense. First of all, barring a 9/11 level catastrophe, football games do not get cancelled. Second, what could think the game is running opposite? If it's something that he'd rather watch, then he would already know about it, and would just go ahead and watch that instead.
The issues go on. Even by the low standards of Lawndale society, the angst generated by lab partnerships is bizarre. OK, take as given the subhuman intelligence of Kevin, Brittany, and the J's, but I still cannot believe that Kevin's visits to Daria's house would be so generally misconstrued. And the final nail in the episode's coffin is the icky Upchuck/Brittany subplot, which somehow manages to be more upsetting than the (multiple!) instances of Quinn being hit on by grown men through the course of the series. Again: none of these things are completely irreconcilable with the rest of the series, and any individual issue is no more noteworthy than, say, the still-in-progress voice characterization of Tiffany. But taken as a whole, they represent a serious challenge to the quality of the show. Fortunately, as the existence of this blog post proves, these shortcomings were far more the exception than the rule.
5. Bullet points!
-The Lab Brat may also suffer in comparison to This Year's Model simply because the latter, as I was surprised to find out, was co-written by Laura Kightlinger, one of my favorite (at the time this aired, and to this day) standup comedians. Check out The Minor Accomplishments of Jackie Woodman, a show you'll be surprised to realize you've never heard of.
-Fun fact about Ms. Barch (who I will definitely be writing more about in future): the actor that did her voice also voiced Tiffany. Which is startling already, and even more so for those of you who are familiar with the finalized voice of Tiffany. Possibly the two most contrasting voices in the show.
-The Lab Brat (particularly the Upchuck nonsense) is clear proof that Eichler was correct that they hadn't really fully articulated The Eichler Principle yet.
-This week in incorrect names: Mr. O'Neill calls Brittany "Normandy." Geography joke!
-This week in incorrect names: Mr. O'Neill calls Brittany "Normandy." Geography joke!
-That said, the principle is quite apparent in This Year's Model. Note that the only models who are made uncomfortable in the episode are the male models. Indeed, the tag on the episode is Kevin being sexualized, objectified, and criticized by representatives of the beauty-industrial complex.
-Daria Timestamp Watch: Brittany has a pager
-In The Lab Brat, Brittany wants to see "the new Whitney Houston movie." Ironically, the last movie that could reasonably be called a "Whitney Houston movie," The Preacher's Wife, came out a good four months before this episode aired. That's presumably the one she's referring to, and it might well still have been in theatres (I don't know how things worked back then), but it's still interesting to realize that, by the time this episode aired, there would be no more "new Whitney Houston movies" for anyone.
-The Lab Brat does have an absolutely fabulous glimpse into Young Jake ("They didn't call it self-love then, Kevin. They called it self-abuse.")
-Kevin, Upchuck, and Jake all request two ice cubes in their soda
-Sick Sad World stories: An encyclopedia written by a model, the Malibu Primate Diet (also a Daria Timestamp Watch there), and "the phone sex/EMS dispatcher." Worth noting that sex work is as sensationalized now as it was back in 1997 (if not more so!)
-Brittany tries to describe the mouse bite on her hand as the fault of a "faulty eyelash curler." Fun fact about me: I was at least 18 years old, if not older, when a female cousin of mine, while going through her purse, happened to pull out an eyelash curler, and I didn't have the faintest idea of what it could be.
-I really love the phone conversation between Helen and Romonica. Not because of the Brazilian wax that's taking place (though that is amusing), but just to hear two confident women who are used to winning arguments go at each other. The exchange: "Please, call me Helen. What can I do for you, Monica?" followed by "Please, call me Romonica" is just exquisite.
-My phone now has "Romonica" in its autocorrect dictionary. As best I can tell, the most prominent Romonica apart from the fictional Daria character is Romonica Harris, who claims to have dated Michael Jackson for five years, and to have been engaged to him.
-Well, that's it for this week! Join me next week, as we meet the Guptys in Pinch Sitter, and dive farther into the psyche of Ms. Barch in Too Cute.